None But the Lonely Heart (1944)

Nominated for 4 Academy Awards:

Best Actor: Cary Grant

Best Supporting Actress: Ethel Barrymore (WON)

Best Editing

Best Music, Scoring of a Dramatic or Comedy Picture

 

It’s strange, and rather unfortunate, that Cary Grant’s two Oscar nominations came for dramatic roles, instead of the comedies he’s so known for nowadays. I say it’s unfortunate because None But the Lonely Heart is not a good film, nor does he deliver a strong performance. I’ve read he was grossly miscast compared to the novel, but that’s not my problem, since I think all characters had been aged for the film and it made sense. The problem is the role simply isn’t much, with a lot of screentime, but a bit of a soulless performance and a character we don’t end up caring for. I am sure Cary has his fault in all of this, by shying away from more impactful, dramatic acting choices, but there wasn’t much on paper to begin with.

A veteran of the stage, Ethel Barrymore came back to the screen after a long absence and won the Oscar for playing the dying mother. I was afraid it might be more of a career win, but she does give a good performance, with some subtle moments and an Oscar-scene at the end.

Otherwise, the film is pretty boring and lacking in energy, excitement or even a captivating story.

 

I give it: 5.5/10

IMDB LINK